Sugar Cookies

$35.99


Baked Fresh Daily, shipped the same day!

Cookies are baked in a facility that produces items containing tree nuts and peanuts.

Customer Reviews
4.9 Based on 37 Reviews
5 ★
92% 
34
4 ★
5% 
2
3 ★
3% 
1
2 ★
0% 
0
1 ★
0% 
0
Customer Photos
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
A
05/19/2025
Anonymous
US US

Just as I remembered

Grew up having sugar cookies from here, don’t have a great American cookie close to me anymore. Ordered online for shipping, and they tasted just as good as I remembered

EO
03/26/2024
Erica O.
US US

Always incredible

Always fresh and tastes amazing!

SS
02/13/2024
Selena S.
US US

Loved them!

The cookies are great, they made it to me in one piece and we are enjoying them. I’m so thankful that we didn’t have to dive the hour to get them in Pensacola. Very convenient and we got them within days.

JP
02/04/2024
Jazma P.
US US

Delicious Cake-like Cookies

The sugar cookies have always been my #1 as a child. They arrived packaged to perfection. The cookies were moist and beyond delightful.

AS
10/30/2023
Angela S.
US US

Reliving My Childhood

I recently ordered sugar cookies to be delivered as I no longer have a Great American Cookie store near me. When I was in middle & high school my favorite part of going to the mall was getting warm cookies from my favorite cookie stand. The only thing different was these were not warm, but they certainly were deliciious just as I remembered them!

Close banner